It's hard to recommend specific cigars because tastes vary, and if you smoke for a while, your tastes will change. Right now, you're probably digging milder smokes. I suggest sticking to some of the reputable, but not huge conglomerate, companies. This site has plenty of affordable cigars by La Aurora, Oliva, Drew Estate. Things like that. Trying buying a five pack from each that looks appealing to you. Don't buy too many of any one thing because (see above) your tastes will change.
Oh, and people are getting ready to make fun of you for smoking flavored cigars. It comes with the territory, don't take it personally. A lot of people start that way, but don't usually stick with flavored stuff that long.