Good ISOM Cohiba’s are just that, very good. The trick is, it's the most commonly counterfeited cigar in the world! I'm sure smith knows a real one though. Also, even with the real ones, I've heard it can be hit or miss. I've experienced this too. Some have been absolutely outstanding!! Some I've lit and then put out... When you get a good one, they're a wonderful medium body smoke, very spicy and cedary.